Skip to main content

Missing from interim arrangement: State enterprise commission

ISSUE

Both Majilses are busy proposing independant commissions that they think will benefit democracy and protecting rights of the people. There is one area they have ignored or have forgotten;
  • Safeguarding the assets of the people owned by state enterprises
  • Protecting state enterprises from bad management and politics.
CORE PROBLEM
State owned companies are often used as a political tool to reward people who show certain affiliations or punish people who refuse to show loyalty towards the establishment. Hence top management team and the Board are often cluttered with people who would not know how to read a financial statement even if it hit them on the head. When it comes to appointment of people to the top jobs in these companies, competencies required to take state enterprises, to a competitive level locally and internationally, often takes a back seat.

The consequence is-
  • At one time or another most of state enterprises have gone bankrupt or have faced serious financial problems because of corruption and also because of bad management.
  • Assets of state enterprises (wholly or partially owned) are often used during political campaigns. These assets include the staff, funds or cash and other assets such as vessels (sea and land).
Hence saving only civil servants (dhaulathuge muvazafun, they are not government servants) is not enough to hold free and fair elections now and beyond. Politicians on all sides need to prevent state enterprises (wholly or partially owned) being misused by any party for political gain.
REMEDY

Introducing totally independant State Enterprise Commission with the mandate of
  • Appointing board of directors to state owned enterprises.
  • nominating people for board of directors in companies that is partially owed by the state
  • regulating state enterprises
  • regulating prices of utilities (electricity, water, basic telephony)
Formula to Appointing members to the commission could be similar to other Commissions already formed.

One may say that all such problems will be solved if we privatized state owned companies. State owned companies that can be privatized should be privatized. The question is do we have time for that during the interim period. Anyhow state ownership of companies will continue since some goods cannot be left to govern based on free market principals. Even if all including utilities are privatized, prices of such companies are regulated in most countries by a commission. In such a mechanism utility prices cannot be used to score political points during election. Till we see such a day, a State enterprise Commission is a must to safeguard assets owned by the people and to protect state enterprises from bad management and politics.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Towards a more equitable budget

The article was published in Maldives Economic Review in its December 2019 Issue 2.  To read the full article click link at end  World Bank in an introductory economic report on Maldives in 1979 states that “Male dominates the political, economic, and social structure of the country. It is here that a small national elite presides over the archipelago's affairs and takes decisions that are crucial to the well-being of the atolls. Not surprisingly, a disproportionate share of government expenditures directly benefits Male and ensures its residents a standard of living that is substantially higher than in the atolls The other islands now rely upon it as their main trading post and contact point with the rest of the world” Fifty years later Male’ has become one of the most congested cities in the world with a population density of 65,201 per km according to National Bureau of Statistics of Maldives. Top reasons for migration as per census is; as a return migrant, educati

Joke: Understanding Maldivian political system

A joke I received from a friend. Modified to add Maldivian flavor. Read and N-joy! Son: "Dad, I have to do a special report for school.Can I ask you a question?" Father:"Sure son. What is the question?" Son: "What is Maldivian Political system?" Father:"Well. let's take our home for example. I'm the head of the family, so let's call me Government. Your mother makes the most decisions in the house ,so let's call her Majlis. We take care of your needs, so let's call you The People.We'll call the maid The Working class and your baby brother we can call The Future. Do you understand son? Son: "I'm not really sure,dad. I'll have to think about it." That night awakened by his brother crying,the boy went to see what was wrong. Discovering that the baby had seriously soiled his diaper,the boy went to his parents room and found his mother sound asleep. He went to the maid's room,where,peeking through

Divide and rule!

We are an unfortunate lot. I mean we are already divided geographically to insignificant proportions making it unsustainable, unfeasible and not viable to do and sustain anything valuable. (On top of that some bigger islands want to stay divided administratively to get two or more councils!!). In this state the perks available to any ruler is ignorance of his subjects, them being busy with their quarrels, arguments, and differences to notice the sorry state they are in. This makes The Maldives a heaven to get power, to stay in power and sustain that power without doing much, for centuries to come! Let me get to the point. According to last census, 75 islands have a population of less than 500, 58 islands have a pop. between 500-1000, and only 65 islands have more than 1000 pop. If I have my way, an inhabited island should have at least 1000 pop (which is not much). If it does not fit the criteria, the people should be offered the option to move to bigger islands. Any i