Skip to main content

Uncle the Developer and the Hypocrites


A headline in Haveeru screams that a certain tourism tycoon has sold his resort for 81 million dollars for 18 years; This 81 million dollar resort has 269 beds; That is 4.4 million dollar per year and  16,728.62 dollar per bed, per year. For that money he bought another resort for 40 million dollars. This 40 million dollar resort has 50 beds; That is 1.25 million dollar per year and 25000 dollar per bed, per year. He must be a really happy man after these deals.

In an another event,  the Majlis  decided that in future, resorts will be charged 8 dollars per square meter as lease rent and  3.5 percent tax from goods and services sold to tourists- in return for extending resort lease period for 50 years. While this movie was being unveiled I thought the political leaders (except from the government) would cry foul as they did for Guantanamo Bay fiasco , firing of Army personal,  municipality land selling, airport deal, electricity hike, No province protest etc...  since the bill was submitted by the government.  At least we got to see the two sides of the coin in each of these incidents. I was looking forward to the debates, the court cases, the protests and so on. However the only thing I heard is silence and more silence regarding the issue. Hypocrites!  It must be the most perfect bill the government has ever submitted and passed by the Majlis.  Is it a fair deal for the people? 

For instance, you give your land for 10 years to develop and within those 10 years the developer (say your uncle) recovers his cost of developing and earns a decent profit. After 10 years you and your children are supposed to get it back and elevate your living standards to another level. However at the end of the lease period ‘Uncle the Developer’ says he wants to make some more profits and pass a Lease Extension Law that mandates to give him an extension of lease period for a nominal fee. Who appointed ‘Uncle the Developer’ to pass the Lease Extension Law? The Children of the Landowner, thinking Uncle knows best.  ‘Uncle the Developer’ continues revising The Lease Extension Law whenever lease period expires and the current lease period is 50 years. You do not have any hope that, you, your children or even your grand children would get the land.  You remain where you were (economically) for a foreseeable future (4 generations?). Would you still say it is a fair deal? Lets do a simple arithmetic.

Total bed capacity of resorts, as of 2008 is 19860. If the citizens of this country have recovered those Islands  at the end of original lease period, and were to sell them for 20000 USD per bed (total resort beds are 19860 as of 2008) per year , we would get about  397,200,000.00 million dollars or 9,076,020,000.00 billion Rufiyaa per year alone from renting those islands. Total government revenue is 7 billion in 2009.

One thing is clear. The head of state (past and current) and this country is controlled by ‘Uncle the Developer’. Who are to blame for this? The People. I mean the Children who sell their vote and vote based on immediate personal favours without thinking long term. The children do not realize that high concentration of ‘Uncle the Developers’ from any one industry in Law making business is bad for the economic health of The Family.

Comments

very good article. totally agree.
//Sub/Corpus said…
true that ...
but uncle developer has played an integral part in the tourism industry before ...
when land owners could not source the funding to develop the resort ...
this may still be the case today ... and uncle come by to save the day in a mutually beneficial business relationship ...
but yes extension are lame ...
starts off with about 25 ... 35 years if the developer can prove to have invested more 10mil ... and now its 50 years ...
Anonymous said…
Had 'Uncle the Developer' been granted an extension on his lease or not, at the current face value at which the tourism business hovers above ground, only uncle and more uncles from different families will be able to afford them at those ridiculous prices - period.

Popular posts from this blog

Joke: Understanding Maldivian political system

A joke I received from a friend. Modified to add Maldivian flavor. Read and N-joy! Son: "Dad, I have to do a special report for school.Can I ask you a question?" Father:"Sure son. What is the question?" Son: "What is Maldivian Political system?" Father:"Well. let's take our home for example. I'm the head of the family, so let's call me Government. Your mother makes the most decisions in the house ,so let's call her Majlis. We take care of your needs, so let's call you The People.We'll call the maid The Working class and your baby brother we can call The Future. Do you understand son? Son: "I'm not really sure,dad. I'll have to think about it." That night awakened by his brother crying,the boy went to see what was wrong. Discovering that the baby had seriously soiled his diaper,the boy went to his parents room and found his mother sound asleep. He went to the maid's room,where,peeking through

Towards a more equitable budget

The article was published in Maldives Economic Review in its December 2019 Issue 2.  To read the full article click link at end  World Bank in an introductory economic report on Maldives in 1979 states that “Male dominates the political, economic, and social structure of the country. It is here that a small national elite presides over the archipelago's affairs and takes decisions that are crucial to the well-being of the atolls. Not surprisingly, a disproportionate share of government expenditures directly benefits Male and ensures its residents a standard of living that is substantially higher than in the atolls The other islands now rely upon it as their main trading post and contact point with the rest of the world” Fifty years later Male’ has become one of the most congested cities in the world with a population density of 65,201 per km according to National Bureau of Statistics of Maldives. Top reasons for migration as per census is; as a return migrant, educati

Can we, women of this country, have some space to grow food and offer food security to our family?

Illustration by Aishath Rishtha   Translation: “When the Last Tree Is Cut Down, the Last Fish Eaten, and the Last Stream Poisoned, You Will Realize That You Cannot Eat Money”  The article was published in  Maldives Economic Review  in its March 2020 Issue 3.  To read the full article click link at end  2014: Think about it? In 2014, I started writing a book using census and all available economic data on every atoll including data on how many uninhabited islands each atoll has. I thought that showing demographic, geographic and economic data will make people realize we need to do something about abandoning such rich resources for a congested living in Male’…. I shared the first draft with friends and mother thinking everyone will be very pleased. They weren’t happy. Major problem seemed to be - “just throwing data on people is not enough… we need to talk about some solutions. Take food security for one…..” Outline of the article 2014: Think about it? 2016: Write a