Skip to main content

Lessons from Worlds’ most expensive ‘concrete junkyard’!


These days, the talks of creating other cities like Male’ is the buzz word. Nobody knows how the Majlis will decide on the issue of granting, another island(s), except Male’, city status by law. The purpose of this post is not to marvel, at the sincerity and commitment of those Mps (especially from the atolls) to meaningful regional development. The million dollar question is do we really want to repeat the Male’ experience? 

Male’ is the health capital, educational capital, infrastructure capital, industry and commerce capital, political capital ...etc of the Maldives. The residents and non-residents alike are paying the price of someone putting all eggs in one basket by squeezing everything under the sun in this tiny place.   There seems to be no end to the rat race for using each and every square meter of land in Male’ for housing shops, offices, Godowns, workshops.....The trees, sun and fresh air have no place here and the ‘ sunny side of life ’ belongs to tourists only, in this part of the Maldives. 

To make it worse, the generations who started families before 30-35 years have to worry about housing for their children, grand children, and even great -great children. The children have nowhere to go except -the sea maybe? Thus each and every person who has even a tiny bit of land wants a 10 storey building that may not be even fit for chickens and pigeons, no matter how shiny and velvety, the inside is! It is sad to say, but Male’ could be, one of the most expensive concrete junkyard in the world!  Previous governments (even current power brokers in the parliament - except one member  maybe) gave a blind eye to the situation.  For instance, we inherited countless regulations on food safety, cleanliness and selling expired items but no such thing to regulate housing for dwelling purposes. 

The previous government initially did try to ease the burden on the City of Male’ and its permanent residents by committing to development of regions and reclaiming land in Male’ itself, followed by villingil and Hulhumale’. Again the objective of this post is not to talk about what went wrong with meaningful regional development or how much of the reclaimed land for Male’ were used fairly and equitably, to provide housing for the residents of Male’.

I guess when you really think about it, none would want to repeat the Male’ experience  because progress of any kind at the cost of trees, sun, fresh air, open spaces, quite residential areas separate from commercial hubs is not worth the price. 

There are so many lessons to be learned by developing regions and cities in the story of Male’. Future councils and planners need to think before making another million dollar mistake by concentrating each and every service in one island. Even the people in bigger islands need to embrace the idea of moving for specialized services; They can go to India for medical purposes and Malaysia for education -right! There is no reason why similar movement within the Maldives cannot be generated. After all sea is part of our life. Perhaps that’s what people are saying in this referendum. We do not want to repeat the Male’ experience!

Comments

//Sub/Corpus said…
i dont think what happened to malé will happen to other proposed cities ...
No anytime soon for sure ...
But i do wonder why they need to be labeled as cities for development to reach them ...
but what ever works them works for them eh ???
Muna Mohamed said…
my fear is what happend to male' could happen if it unchecked and gave a go without proper planning. cities should be planned before the demand destroys the enviournment and beauty of it. thanks for the comments
Anonymous said…
Male is not the problem here. If you've been to largest cities like london it is congested too and we need good regulations to govern it. What we seen from Male' is an effort made by the past generation and it has so many value.
Muna Mohamed said…
London or Paris little bit of greenery, space and sunshine is a must in residential areas. commercial districts can get as ugly as they like. some planning is needed for future if you want beautiful island cities
Anonymous said…
Need a better critique on this topic. This is the same old shit that everyone speaks abt.
"Change your thoughts and you change your world"-Norman Vincent Peale.

Popular posts from this blog

Divide and rule!

We are an unfortunate lot. I mean we are already divided geographically to insignificant proportions making it unsustainable, unfeasible and not viable to do and sustain anything valuable. (On top of that some bigger islands want to stay divided administratively to get two or more councils!!). In this state the perks available to any ruler is ignorance of his subjects, them being busy with their quarrels, arguments, and differences to notice the sorry state they are in. This makes The Maldives a heaven to get power, to stay in power and sustain that power without doing much, for centuries to come! Let me get to the point. According to last census, 75 islands have a population of less than 500, 58 islands have a pop. between 500-1000, and only 65 islands have more than 1000 pop. If I have my way, an inhabited island should have at least 1000 pop (which is not much). If it does not fit the criteria, the people should be offered the option to move to bigger islands. Any i

Can we, women of this country, have some space to grow food and offer food security to our family?

Illustration by Aishath Rishtha   Translation: “When the Last Tree Is Cut Down, the Last Fish Eaten, and the Last Stream Poisoned, You Will Realize That You Cannot Eat Money”  The article was published in  Maldives Economic Review  in its March 2020 Issue 3.  To read the full article click link at end  2014: Think about it? In 2014, I started writing a book using census and all available economic data on every atoll including data on how many uninhabited islands each atoll has. I thought that showing demographic, geographic and economic data will make people realize we need to do something about abandoning such rich resources for a congested living in Male’…. I shared the first draft with friends and mother thinking everyone will be very pleased. They weren’t happy. Major problem seemed to be - “just throwing data on people is not enough… we need to talk about some solutions. Take food security for one…..” Outline of the article 2014: Think about it? 2016: Write a

Towards a more equitable budget

The article was published in Maldives Economic Review in its December 2019 Issue 2.  To read the full article click link at end  World Bank in an introductory economic report on Maldives in 1979 states that “Male dominates the political, economic, and social structure of the country. It is here that a small national elite presides over the archipelago's affairs and takes decisions that are crucial to the well-being of the atolls. Not surprisingly, a disproportionate share of government expenditures directly benefits Male and ensures its residents a standard of living that is substantially higher than in the atolls The other islands now rely upon it as their main trading post and contact point with the rest of the world” Fifty years later Male’ has become one of the most congested cities in the world with a population density of 65,201 per km according to National Bureau of Statistics of Maldives. Top reasons for migration as per census is; as a return migrant, educati